I got the crazy horse leather and it's very nice. Looking forward to the patina it develops over time. Smells awesome, very rich leather smell! I've worn them for about 10 days now and they are breaking in nicely, no issues right out of the box. I'm a 13 in everything and that's what I ordered. They are roomy but don't feel oversized, great stitching and attention to details. I ordered the black as well but haven't worn them yet, again, very rich smell and nice polished leather, looking forward to these boots.